tabf5
1 week ago
i guess they're also the same color of a GPU company that might pop the AI bubble because the CEO was too horny
diremptiness
1 week ago
Wait I have a color? I thought I was more on the yellow side unless the white balance on that picture is off
tabf5
1 week ago
Yeah I used a cheap point-and-shoot for this pic but these scissors are the EXACT yellow-green as your homepage
tabf5
1 week ago
NEW PHOTO UPDATE! The tablings be like: that's my grandpa. You'll see what I mean when you see it Also I moved some buttons around on my wall and sent a shitload of stickers out to my fellow Americans. Did you know Bississippi was confirmed btw?
fishforfree
1 week ago
Easily accessible LLM Chatbots are a Problem, but i don't think literally every Instance of AI is bad (f.e Video game AIs are also a Form of Agent). Be proud of yourself for a critical thought, dogmatism is always wrong.
art1st1x
1 week ago
It happens. In a world where this technology is ever-evolving, it is getting seriously difficult to determine in what ways usage of it can be considered harmful. It's unfortunate that the two furthest extents of beliefs often don't believe there's any justification for a viewpoint in between them.
cco0orn
1 week ago
Oml that's so dumb to unfollow just for AI discourse thing, those techbros are delulu af :/
tabf5
1 week ago
Thanks guys, also @cco0orn @frerg I actually think the unfollows were from people who didn't think I was anti-AI enough. I defended Big Walk's use of it instead of swearing them off like a small subset of hardcore anti-AI people have been, though at this point I feel like you have to stop using computers soon if you're that intense about it
humanfinny
1 week ago
Id rather House House disclose all the times they used LLMs instead of just one example. Hate the argument that some make that it's "inevitable", it's like saying capitalism, poverty, natural resource extraction is inevitable... like, no, we are the ones doing it lmao. Otherwise agree with you on this.
tabf5
1 week ago
@humanfinny Yeah I think we should absolutely keep scrutinizing any game dev or artist who uses it going forward. It's harder to argue when it comes to functional software or tools, but games are art and they should be considered worth less if any humans were ever replaced to make them without trying every other option first. House House gets a ONE-TIME pass here because they probably didn't know, but now they do
a9scorner
1 week ago
im not forcing again or anything, but cbox and divcord both have automod. plus, you can assign trustworthy people to be mods.
anypup
1 week ago
10 lines of code isn't that bad.. especially as a mobile user who saw entirely genAI games on the play store..
tabf5
1 week ago
if AI wasn't chained to a cloud subscription data center and instead actually accessible to everyone without a $100000 GPU, I think people would be more forgiving for technical use cases like this where not even the developers of the game engine could figure out a bug. AI should absolutely be nowhere in art/music either. this extends to web dev since HTML/CSS/JS is ridiculously easy compared to low-level engine code
tabf5
1 week ago
look at all these justifications I have to write though. am I even still anti-AI even though I want to be? gray areas like these is why I put "human-made" and "pro-human" instead of full on Fuck AI because I was afraid this would happen. this is so conflicting
tabf5
1 week ago
@anypup They used it multple times for bugs that not even the devs at Unity themselves could figure out. Somehow I can forgive them for it because I'd be lying if I said otherwise. but I'm scared that I'm giving AI an inch and now a mile will be taken
lydels
1 week ago
it does suck that this will be used as justification but i think we also need these sorts of cases in order to have a proper anti-AI stance. we need to learn to apply nuance and understand what it is exactly that we're fighting against. saying that all AI is evil is easy but it's too vague and just not good enough if we're trying to actually change something and debate in meaningful ways...
lydels
1 week ago
oops the comments updated when i posted and i just saw yours lol. nuance is a good thing!! you're not less anti AI, it's just that this is a GIGANTIC topic to debate that is also constantly evolving, and drawing a line on what we can and can not say is not only impossible but also unhelpful i think. you might be wrong or i might be wrong about something but closing ourselves off to debate is worse than being wrong
frerg
1 week ago
it's 10 lines of code but it's pretty heartbreaking to see those news in your favorite game
tabf5
1 week ago
@lydels Yeah I think this is really making everyone confront the nuance very publicly in a good way. Still very scary times ofc
anypup
1 week ago
@tabf5 oohh i thought they just used it once minor fixes here and there for issues not even support can fix is fine in my eyes but yet again, life is complicated and it always depends on the situation
oscarspage
1 week ago
GenAI illustrations or "art" give me an aneurysm but I feel nothing when it's used for code. Tbh it's just too good at it. In my opinion it's like being against the use of compilers.
wtpi
1 week ago
i dislike ai in art as much as the next guy, but as far as ai use goes i find this to be relatively inoffensive. it's not like they're actively using it as part of their workflow or to replace the work of real people or anything like that. i get why people might be hesitant about them using it at all but in this specific use case i don't personally take much issue with it
bondioli
1 week ago
For smaller projects especially, I'm surprised that studios don't use AI for programming more. Say what you will about intellectual property rights on public code that these models trained on, but in the end code either works, or it doesn't. Whether or not AI was used to make the thing work on a technical level doesn't matter all too much to me personally, but I can see why other's don't like it
bondioli
1 week ago
For creative works it's more about human direction over authorship for technical info. I see the code as an obstacle to making the game work, where other assets (models, textures, sounds, music, writing, etc) are art pieces in their own right, where an AI-made piece would probably compromise the artistic intent. Just my 2 cents
bondioli
1 week ago
Actually wrote a blog post about this recently lol https://bondio.li/blogs/post?post=blog14
tabf5
1 week ago
I think we have to keep in mind that fully dismissing what House House did here is saying that coding is not an art form "worthy enough" to remain fully human
tabf5
1 week ago
@bondioli Yeah you mentioned the novel movement system in Celeste than an AI could probably never think of itself. Sure you can argue that the code itself perhaps isnt "art" but having the idea and throwing prompts at it reach the same discovery as someone who actually messes with the code directly to discover what Celeste's movement style will be? Happy accidents from directly engaging the process contribute greatly
lentil-brainworld
1 week ago
I’d feel better if they laid out all the times they used the LLM instead of just one example - clearly since the bugs have been fixed then there WAS a solution out there, otherwise the LLM wouldn’t have been able to take it and spit it back out in a state they had to modify anyway. This doesn’t make me hate the game - there is no game like Big Walk, it was genuinely a life-changing experience and
lentil-brainworld
1 week ago
im so glad it brought me and my brothers closer together even long after we’ve finished everything the game has to offer - but I will be wary of what House House makes next, and I’ll hope they’ll stay away from LLMs entirely for their next project or at least be fully transparent right from when they use it that they’re doing so, instead of this long after the game has been released
bondioli
1 week ago
Definitely agree there, the systems powered by programming can be artful, and the quality of the system/mechanics in the game itself can vary depending on how heavily AI was leveraged, and for what. AI is best used for elements of a game that have been done before in other games with slight changes, or when you have a very clear idea in mind for a system. If you're having AI think for you, then what's the point...
kockatriceking
1 week ago
man at the risk of gettin jumped im gonna be so fr. i see AI as a hammer. pretty useful in some contexts. can cause a lot of harm in other contexts. keeps getting pushed on jobs that absolutely dont need a hammer because when youre a techbro everything looks like a nail. and like of all the things a machine is good at, coding is probably the one thing you expect it to know. 90% of coding is searching shit up anyway
brachypelmide
1 week ago
honestly even though i despise LLMs at a fundamental level, if even the engine devs themselves cannot help you then like. all punches allowed. it sucks that they used AI but as far as AI usage goes this is one of the least offensive ways to do it
vtipoman
1 week ago
Personally, I draw the line between analytical AI used with human oversight (it can be quite good at those tasks) and genAI (slop).
deerdear
1 week ago
YOO thank u for the heads up, i heard about it a long while ago but didn't know when it'd open
cottonjewel
1 week ago
You don't have to fill that out but just pick a random landscape you think suits it if you wanna pick it
samsolarsystem
1 week ago
why isn't space a landscape option?! oh well it doesn't matter, this is a super cool project and I've already sent my application! thank you so much for sharing this :D
moon-room
1 week ago
You know what? Why not? Maybe I should fill the form out just for the hell of it
v0idspace
1 week ago
I submitted to them a while ago. Love this idea so much. I hope they restock the first book, i missed out :(
thepinklair
1 week ago
i had no idea about this project until now :0 its so cool!! sent an application :]
cco0orn
1 week ago
Never heard about this project before, looks fun! I'll try to submit my own in future...
taren
1 week ago
This is an awesome idea! I think I'll apply, but I'm not really convinced by the sheer amount of corporate-oriented sites in the first issue
@aznet why do you comment random drivel on everyone's posts
Thanks, I'm glad you enjoyed my writing. I will say I'm a bit distressed by how widely my post has been shared at this point. A lot of context has gotten lost, but I don't think people would benefit from context being dredged up for/by those who weren't there either. But I'm glad people have been rallying against the collapse of collaborative, creative spaces online in the face of it.
I'm focusing my attention on my job and making things (be it art, tools, games) these days, mostly. I'm still trying to use and contribute to Bevy, but it's emotionally difficult to engage with at this point.