hot take: dynamism is a stronger indicator of “good representation” than whether or not the character is a virtuous person or even whether they meet or don’t meet a checkbox list of stereotypes to avoid.
a character from a marginalized group can be an upstanding citizen; but if they don’t change, grow, or experience challenges throughout the story, whereas other characters do, that indicates to me that the creator sees them as less of a person.
sometimes when i make points like this i’m asked what i propose people do instead. to be honest, i don’t really know. i know i can’t make anyone do anything. i’m just tired of having to suck it up when creatives openly admit that they don’t like to think about people who look like me unless they absolutely have to.
a character from a marginalized group can be an upstanding citizen; but if they don’t change, grow, or experience challenges throughout the story, whereas other characters do, that indicates to me that the creator sees them as less of a person.
sometimes when i make points like this i’m asked what i propose people do instead. to be honest, i don’t really know. i know i can’t make anyone do anything. i’m just tired of having to suck it up when creatives openly admit that they don’t like to think about people who look like me unless they absolutely have to.