misanthropology
5 days ago
Couldn't you use a similar argument for solipsism? I.e., saying that my "now" is the only *real* now (all those past nows can't really be nows) looks rather similar to saying that my experiences are the only experiences. If my today-now is realer than my yesterday-now, why shouldn't it be realer than your today-now? It's subjectively realer, but not... real-ly.
misanthropology
5 days ago
Still a very good post, btw. I realize I only comment when feeling contrary.
rainight
5 days ago
Doesn't this imply that time (and everything else) ceases to exist the moment you pass away?
misanthropology
5 days ago
Maybe? I'm not trying to argue that solipsism is true, only that if that argument works for one it should work for the other; ergo it doesn't work. I guess I'm getting caught up on what it is that makes the present more real than the past. It's true that my experience of the now can only be right now... but it's also true that my experience of being a person can only be for me (right here, so to speak).
misanthropology
5 days ago
And if other people can experience that being-a-me-ness, or that here-ness, then it seems odd to claim that only the present has now-ness. Or the words "this" and "that" in connection to pointing; of course "this" is what I'm pointing at (saying "this is what I'm pointing at" is usually the same as saying "I'm pointing", unless you can enhance your pointing) but you can (or other people can) point at other things.
rainight
4 days ago
I think there's a difference between "only MY now" is real and "only the present is real" with the idea that the present is objectively real for all observers.
misanthropology
4 days ago
Good point! I should have said "this" now, not "my" now. Rephrasing the argument: if "this" now is the real now, then why shouldn't "this" experience be the (only) real experience? As in: "this" experience I am having now (seeing the screen, typing, etc) as opposed to the experiences of others. (Note: I realize that I keep on using the past tense in my argument for the past; it's a bit silly.)
rainight
2 days ago
I'll appeal to intuition and say it's because solipsism is far less intuitive than presentism. The idea that my mind is the only one that exists is a scary thought, but the idea that only the present is real is more acceptable. I know that's not a rigorous argument, but I think most people will find it convincing.
misanthropology
1 day ago
That's a good point, and probably what it boils down to. It's even worth mentioning that a lot of the conflicts between presentism and relativity depend on the reality of other minds to have presents in them.
rainight
1 week ago
Guess who joined a webring!! That's the first time I got something out of being left-handed.
I took the test and scored 162, I win!
It’s baffling that most people don’t examine their world view!
Can't believe you don't want to join the club.