Discrete Ideas

discreteideas.neocities.org

20,942 views
33 followers
542 updates
0 tips
discreteideas updated their site.
3 days ago
3 likes
rainight's avatar rainight 3 days ago

Mr. Ideas, I believe the catholic church (in magnifica humanitas) officially rejected the idea that computational systems can ever obtain personhood or consciousness. I wonder if you have any thoughts on the matter.

3 likes
discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 3 days ago

It's been a while since I read it so I can't really speak to the arguments made in Magnifica Humanitas. I don't think AI is a person now, but I do think it could (possibly) become one (depending on how "personhood" turns out to work!). Ultimately though, I don't think the Roman Catholic Church rejecting something necessarily makes it so. (I am not a Roman Catholic)

1 like
discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 3 days ago

(not to say that Roman Catholics think everything the pope says is true - For Roman Catholics the pope only speaks infallibly on rare occasions - never in my lifetime I think)

3 likes
aredia's avatar aredia 3 days ago

I think a clear argument for this is that these models lack one of the most important elements of personhood which is that of a will. They merely compute based on an input and a super complex and nigh unintelligible statistical model (the LLM) to give an output. The models themselves are nothing but a highly complex and intricate next token predictor with some extra stuff added in like system prompts or harnesses.

4 likes
discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 3 days ago

Absolutely. But the question is, is there a fundamental limitation of ANNs that will forever prevent them from having a will? If a “soul” is a metaphysical extra then certainly, but if “souls” are emergent then I’m not so sure. Simply being mechanistic doesn’t necessarily disqualify one from personhood.

1 like
rainight's avatar rainight 2 days ago

If AI gains a will or a "soul", then can it go to heaven or hell?

2 likes
yattsukeshigoto's avatar yattsukeshigoto 2 days ago

@rainight, it can't, because humans are miraculously created in the womb, and AI is manmade. It's also important to note that companies are trying to build AGI via LLM agents working in tandem, which means that AGI will theoretically 'think' completely in plaintext, which is several times less complex than how human brains think.

2 likes
rainight's avatar rainight 2 days ago

(Agreed. I heavily disagree with reductionism, but I wanted to hear Mr.Idea's thoughts because he does not reject the possibility of man-made souls)

discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 2 days ago

@rainight I have no idea!

1 like
discreteideas updated their site.
6 days ago
5 likes
discreteideas updated their site.
1 week ago
4 likes
vihmu's avatar vihmu 1 week ago

i also can confirm from personal experience that coffee and tea taste best when they're made the simplest way :)

4 likes
discreteideas updated their site.
1 week ago
4 likes
discreteideas updated their site.
2 weeks ago
6 likes
literaturegirl's avatar literaturegirl 2 weeks ago

I think something that helps me in approaching such tensions (which I have had to do often, especially throughout my degree in theology) is the acceptance that certain aspects of God simply are incomprehensible to us, and that that's okay. It's certainly important to attempt to link science and reason back to God, and the philosophy of religion was actually my favourite subdiscipline within my degree — (cont.)

4 likes
literaturegirl's avatar literaturegirl 2 weeks ago

However, I think one of the most important things it taught me was humility about how much I truly can know. I think sometimes we're also just not necessarily ready for God to reveal certain things to us, also.

4 likes
literaturegirl's avatar literaturegirl 2 weeks ago

Interesting to read articles from someone with Anglo-Catholic sentiment, also! I grew up Anglican in the UK and became increasingly 'High Church' in my beliefs before eventually converting to Catholicism. I never seemed to meet many other High Church Anglicans, even within Anglican parishes! I attended some lovely Anglo-Catholic worship back then.

3 likes
discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 1 week ago

Interesting! Might be that Anglo Catholic parishes are more concentrated in bigger cities? But I only know my experiences

2 likes
discreteideas updated their site.
2 weeks ago
6 likes
christ-lover's avatar christ-lover 2 weeks ago

Love this! I know a guy myself that's gonna be a chemistry teacher soon and he's also very Christian so there's more people that think like you for sure, me included too :) As Newton once said “Atheism is so senseless. When I look at the solar system, I see the earth at the right distance from the sun to receive the proper amounts of heat and light. This did not happen by chance.”

2 likes
discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 2 weeks ago

Thanks! I really believe we can be both fully Christian and fully scientific

2 likes
rainight's avatar rainight 2 weeks ago

I don't get it. Where is the tension?

2 likes
discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 2 weeks ago

An obvious tension might be that we have the Genesis creation narrative and the theory of evolution. I have also written recently about Thomistic metaphysics, which is commonly used by Christians, and the rather large tensions with actual physics (23/10/26) - although I appreciate you disagree with me here

1 like
rainight's avatar rainight 2 weeks ago

I thought many dont interpret genesis and friends literally, do they? And my understanding is that it's a normal orthodox religious view judging by some of the authors I've read. Also, Thomastic metaphysics is not science though? Even if it was, it was never religion either and you can just ignore it or disagree with it, so I still fail to see the tension.

1 like
discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 2 weeks ago

I don't think we are using "tension" in the same sense. I suppose you mean something like a paradox that can't be resolved. I mean tension in the sense of ideas and ways of thinking pulling away from each other. So for example many people DO take genesis very literally and many others do use literal genesis to mock / attack Christianity. So obviously this tension can be resolved by thinking about it in a certain way

3 likes
discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 2 weeks ago

but that doesn't mean the tension doesn't exist. And I won't restate my argument on Thomistic metaphysics other than to say it very much was the "science" of it's day as I argued in my post on the 23rd of October.

1 like
rainight's avatar rainight 2 weeks ago

So what? The founders of the Christian faith preached God and salvation, not Thomisim or Aristotle.The tension feels artificial because it's produced by a caricture of faith. It's not science vs religion, it's science vs bad religion.

1 like
discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 2 weeks ago

You endorsed Edward Feser's book with a 10/10 review, writing: "this book aims to show that Aristotelian metaphysics isn’t merely defensible and compatible with science, but necessary for there to be any science in the first place."

1 like
discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 2 weeks ago

Feser is the premier modern Thomist. Yet now, the moment I point out the tension between Thomism and empirical physics, Thomist metaphysics is suddenly "bad religion" and a "caricature of faith"? Call me baffled.

1 like
discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 2 weeks ago

And let's just say I am wrong about Thomism. Maybe it is completely correct. But there is still a tension, if there isn't why did Feser write a ~500 page book trying to reconcile Thomism with modern physics. If there is no tension, why even do that? The WHOLE project of Feser is to reconcile Catholic Thomism with science.....

rainight's avatar rainight 2 weeks ago

You're missing the point. I'm saying that even if you were right (and I don't think you are) and Thomism is complete lunacy, then so what? Who cares? What does this have to do anything with the God of Christianity? I don't recall Jesus preaching hylomorphism or teleology so it shouldn't matter if they turn out to be complete nonsense.

1 like
vihmu's avatar vihmu 2 weeks ago

sorry to enter "uninvited", but i'm siding with Rainight on this one matters that are unessential to a Christian's salvation are, perhaps, better taken at face value, rather than seeing them as "tensions" in our faith. i do not think a Christian grandma will find it very helpful to get slandered because she doesn't know "proper" metaphysics. we are to reflect Christ's teaching in our actions and thoughts God bless

2 likes
discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 2 weeks ago

Ok well let’s just forget about anything not mentioned by Jesus. The trinity. The Eucharist. Natural law. Divine simplicity and Vihmu your point is just pastoral. My grandma does not need advanced theology, but I’m still allowed to think about it

discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 2 weeks ago

And rainight I just do not get your point. You’re essentially saying we don’t need to reconcile theology (and Thomism is a massive part of western Christianity) with reason. That’s actually mad.

vihmu's avatar vihmu 2 weeks ago

@discreteideas when did i say to ignore anything not explicitly mentioned by Jesus? (also Jesus *does* talk of the Eucharist... and His relationship to the Trinity...) I also did not mean that you are not allowed to think about advanced theology. I am sorry but this argument doesn't seem to be going anywhere. I was referring to interpretations of Scripture and Theology that are not essential to one's salvation

1 like
discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 2 weeks ago

I just don’t understand the issue with admitting to “tension”. It just seems manifestly obvious to me that with an imperfect understanding of science and theology we are going to have tensions between the two domains of thought.

rainight's avatar rainight 2 weeks ago

No? I didn't say that. I said Thomism is not Christianity.

1 like
discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 2 weeks ago

@vihmu Honestly, I’m tired of going in circles over semantic games. I stand by everything in my original post based on a common-sense understanding of English and the real world, and I won't be replying further.

1 like
discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 2 weeks ago

Thomism is the official philosophy of the Catholic Church. I’m done here

vihmu's avatar vihmu 2 weeks ago

i am sorry you feel that way, i did not mean to upset you. i am not perfect, and the Lord knows that very well. God bless you

rainight's avatar rainight 2 weeks ago

I wonder if neocities' moderators will be puzzled by the number of comments under this update. Hey mods, did we break the world record? I have to know!

1 like
christ-lover's avatar christ-lover 2 weeks ago

Well that certainly exploded after my comment 😅

christ-lover's avatar christ-lover 2 weeks ago

But I hope y'all are not too upset at each other 🙏🏻

2 likes
discreteideas updated their site.
2 weeks ago
5 likes
rainight's avatar rainight 2 weeks ago

I thought hell was for the wicked, not those who don't believe? Isn't the consensus that "good" non-believers are also saved?

1 like
rainight's avatar rainight 2 weeks ago

> granted the grace to believe during this life Is grace another word for statistics? ;) If faith is the only criteria for being saved then that makes it mostly a matter of where you're born given that the vast majority of believers are believers because they were born into belief. Is God playing with dice? I don't like luck based games.

2 likes
discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 2 weeks ago

Hell is for the wicked. The Christian question is who is righteous enough for heaven in their own right. Who amoung us has never sinned? This is why Christians believe we need Christ to save us, because we can’t do it by our own “goodness”

3 likes
discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 2 weeks ago

The hope I am expressing is not the hope that all “good” people are saved. It is the hope that Christ has saved all people

2 likes
discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 2 weeks ago

I think we basically agree though. I don't like the geographic luck idea

2 likes
discreteideas updated their site.
2 weeks ago
4 likes
discreteideas updated their site.
3 weeks ago
3 likes
duvarki's avatar duvarki 3 weeks ago

I once was visiting a rural church for a service where all the parish congregations came together for that Sunday. Even still it was only ~40 people, all elderly. During the sermon I looked at one of the centuries-old windows and saw a little play area that had been set up in the corner. As the sun shone through I saw it covered in dust and cobwebs. Somehow it made me tear up a little, it was such a poignant sight.

1 like
discreteideas's avatar discreteideas 2 weeks ago

it is definitely sad to see such places in a dilapidated state. I suppose its because all those generations of people invested their efforts in a place only for times to change

1 like
discreteideas updated their site.
3 weeks ago
3 likes

Website Stats

Last updated 3 days ago
CreatedMar 5, 2026

Tags

christianity faith philosophy christian anglican